Disclaimer: There are affiliate links in this post. At no cost to you, I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.

Brake Cleaner Vs Carb Cleaner: What’s the Difference?

Brake Cleaner Vs Carb Cleaner: What’s the Difference?

Brake Cleaner Vs Carb Cleaner – the age-old question for mechanics and vehicle owners alike.

While the two products perform the same basic function, some differences are essential to understand.

Carb cleaner is designed to tackle the buildup of residue and grime that accumulates in your carburetor, while brake cleaner is formulated to remove oil, grease, and dirt from brakes and other automotive parts.

Both are equally important for keeping your vehicle running smoothly, and choosing the right cleaner for the job is essential.


What Is a Carb Cleaner? (Carburetor Cleaner)

Carb cleaner is a versatile chemical solution that can clean all sorts of gunk buildups from different engine parts. Your engine can accumulate dirt, oil, carbon, debris, and other deposits, which impede performance.

While carb cleaning solvent has a reputation for causing minimal engine metal damage, it leaves a slightly oily residue behind. However, there’s a catch to the usefulness of this solution. If you want to keep the paint on your vehicle, kindly resist using the key on painted surfaces. The color will come right off.

A fun fact about this solution: It was initially created to clean the carburetors of older vehicles. The carburetor is part of the car that mixes fuel and air into the internal combustion chamber, thus sparking ignition power behind the car. As time went by, particles created would leave deposits all over the inside of the room, which had to be cleaned. So, a potent mixture of chemicals was created to remove the particles for proper carburetor function.

Once the proper combination of chemicals was discovered, it was realized that the fluid could be used to clean other parts as well, as long as it was done safely, as the chemicals can be dangerous in the wrong hands. Carb cleaner mixes Acetone, Xylene, Toluene, Methyl Ethyl Ketone, Ethyl Benzene, 2-Butoxyethanol, and propane.

Therefore, proper care must be taken when handling the mixture. If you want to distinguish between carb cleaner and brake cleaner, note that carb cleaner tends to leave a residue. Some mechanics don’t worry about this aspect of the cleaner, whereas others are more meticulous about leaving no residue behind.

Carburetor Cleaner Reviews

Let’s explore Carb Cleaner’s ingredients, uses, customer reviews, and performance to reveal the truth about its effectiveness.

-Carb Cleaner Uses

Carburetor cleaner efficiently breaks down oil and dirt buildup in internal combustion engines. Its use is not limited to vehicles, extending to machines like lawnmowers, tractors, snow blowers, and sometimes motorcycles. Whether cleaning individual parts or complete engines, carburetor cleaner is a dependable solution for optimizing engine performance.

-Carb Cleaner Ingredients

While effective, carburetor cleaners consist of hazardous materials that need to be handled cautiously. To help you stay informed, the solvent is an aerosol spray made up of the following chemicals:

  • Xylene
  • Methyl Ethyl Ketone
  • 2-butoxyethenol
  • Propane
  • Ethyl Benzene
  • Acetone
  • Toluene

Carb cleaner can be flammable and even explosive if not used properly.

Therefore, it is always recommended for users to:

  • wear safety garments and gloves,
  • avoid inhaling any vapors during use,
  • refrain from smoking, eating, and drinking while using the cleaner,
  • only spray the product in a well-ventilated area, and
  • follow all safety and storage instructions listed on the product labels.

Environmental standards require specific disposal instructions.

-Carb Cleaner Performance

One can of high-quality carburetor cleaner is enough to obliterate layers of deposits, leaving your engine running like new.

The strength and effectiveness of this powerful chemical compound is contingent upon the level of contaminants present in the engine.

However, with the proper use of carb cleaner, you can improve your fuel economy and overall engine performance, as harmful buildup that inhibits acceleration and responsiveness is removed.

-Carb Cleaner Customer Reviews

Carburetor cleaners do get the job done, but only with correct usage. Many mistakenly think spraying one surface area is enough to remove engine buildup. In reality, disassembly to reveal smaller parts and individual spraying of each one is required for a comprehensive cleaning.

Opt for popular cleaners with low VOC content and eco-friendly compounds to avoid these mishaps. Besides being environmentally conscious, they offer surface flexibility and fast-acting formulas for efficient and lasting results.

What Is a Brake Cleaner?

Brake cleaner was primarily designed for keeping brake pads and rotors sparkling clean to optimize their performance. However, to everyone’s surprise, its potent formula became a versatile cleaning solution for other parts. What’s more, it doesn’t leave any nasty residue behind. No wonder many mechanics and DIYers favor brake cleaner over carb cleaner.

The beauty of brake cleaner is how effortlessly it can restore the brake components’ shine by spraying it on the moving parts and letting the powerful formula work its magic. The chemicals eat right through the dirt and grime, leaving the brake system looking like new. Not only that, but it dries quickly so that you can hit the road confidently in no time.

While brake cleaner does an exceptional job of cleaning off dirt, grime, oil, and other deposits, it comes in two distinct types, with one variant considered safer. So, make sure you choose the appropriate type for your cleaning needs.

Brake Cleaner Reviews

Please find below a detailed explanation of the brake cleaner and the alternative cleaning solution under consideration:

-Brake Cleaner Uses

Brake cleaner is formulated to efficiently dissolve oil, dirt, grime, and road debris on hydraulic systems. Additionally, it is instrumental in eliminating stubborn contaminants, such as tar, from the exterior of vehicles, bike chains, and surfaces like concrete or decking. Its versatile cleaning abilities make it an essential tool for mechanics, motorists, and bikers alike.

-What Is Brake Cleaner Made Of?

Brake cleaner, a chemical blend containing alcohols and hydrocarbon solvents, poses huge flammability risks and detrimental impacts on the environment.

Even though chlorinated brake cleaners demonstrate more potency, they can cause corrosion to metals and other surfaces.

It is imperative for users to wear protective gloves, keep the product away from heat sources, refrain from smoking, and only use it in well-ventilated spaces.

Inhalation of vapors is hazardous and could cause instant dizziness and drowsiness. Remember to follow the strict disposal and storage guidelines on the product labels. Stay safe!

-Brake Cleaner Performance

Brake cleaners are highly effective in clearing up buildup on the mechanisms of hydraulic systems. This results in a noticeable improvement in overall system performance.

Even brake cleaners specialize in reducing brake noises by eliminating friction-causing materials.

This innovative solution can bring peace of mind to drivers who have grown used to suffering from excessive brake noise and allow for a more enjoyable driving experience.

-Brake Cleaner Customer Reviews

Brake cleaner users value quick-drying and low-residue products. However, compatibility with different materials and safety standards are critical for informed buying decisions, given the variety of compounds. As with carb cleaners, low VOC content is preferred. While brake cleaners are generally more expensive, buying bulk is a smart option for consumers who hope to save upfront.

Your Guide to Brake Cleaner and Carburetor Cleaner | What’s the Difference? 

Keeping dirt, debris, and oil away from brake parts is essential for efficient braking and to avoid potential accidents. On the other hand, cleaning a carburetor can be quite tricky as it involves both removing stubborn dirt and using oil to free up valves or linkages.

To achieve an oil-free surface on brake components, PJ1 Brake Cleaner is your best bet. With its professional formulation and high-pressure spray, this powerful cleaner ensures that your brake components are thoroughly cleaned and ready for maximum braking power. But beware, this cleaner is meant only for non-painted metal surfaces as it could cause damage to rubber, plastic and electrical components.

However, if you are looking to clean electrical components without harming them, PJ1 Contact Cleaner is what you need. It removes carbon build-up, dirt, and dust from electrical components, leaving them clean and functioning properly.

For carburetor cleaning, PJ1 Carburetor Cleaner is the ideal solution. This specially-formulated cleaner removes varnish and tough deposits effortlessly, freeing up stuck components and restoring your carburetor to its original condition. Moreover, it’s safe for rubber, vinyl, and neoprene seals or gaskets, which means there’s no need to rebuild your carburetor after cleaning. Just remember to keep it away from plastics and painted surfaces and test it on a small spot first. Keep your vehicle in top-notch condition with PJ1!

What Cleans Better: Carb Cleaner or Brake Cleaner?

While some argue that brake cleaners leave less residue than carb cleaners, making them the preferred option, there are drawbacks to consider.

Carb cleaners can clean more engine components safely and effectively than brake cleaners.

Additionally, brake cleaners may be more chemically toxic and harsh on surfaces and should only be used for cleaning brake systems.

Therefore, selecting the right cleaner for your needs involves considering various factors for optimal cleaning performance.

Can You Use Carb Cleaner Instead of Brake Cleaner?

It’s always a good idea to distinguish carburetor cleaner from brake cleaner. Putting carburetor cleaner in your vehicle’s hydraulic system can be bad news — with the potential to cause lasting damage and hamper a vehicle’s ability to slow down.

One crucial difference between the two cleaners is that brake cleaner is designed to leave no oil behind, while carburetor cleaner leaves a slight oil residue that may aid the operation of the engine parts it touches.

So next time, make sure you choose the right cleaner for the job, and you’ll be one step closer to a successful vehicle operation!

Can I Use Brake Cleaner Instead of Carb Cleaner?

When cleaning your car’s parts, you must get it right. Using the right cleaner can lead to disastrous results that could save you plenty of time and money. That’s why it’s essential to use carburetors and brake cleaners correctly and to respect the difference between them.

Carburetors and brake cleaners are two completely different formulas that accomplish other tasks. While it’s true that it costs less to buy each type of cleaner separately, it’s important to remember that the price you might pay for the wrong choice far outweighs the cost of purchasing the correct cleaners.

Now, you may find yourself with only one type of cleaner available. But if you can’t get your hands on carb cleaner and instead have a suitable brake cleaner on standby, you can make do by using it. Just make sure that the formula is non-harmful for specific car parts, and avoid using it if it isn’t specified.

In conclusion, never use carburetor cleaners on your brakes – the risks far outweigh the benefits. Instead, choose a contact brake cleaner that is safe to use on non-metal materials, and ensure that it’s the right fit for the cleaning task. Keep your car parts in tip-top shape, and enjoy your ride!

Which One Should You Go For?

Carburetor cleaners are a better choice for engine parts as compared to brake cleaning solvents. Not only are they less expensive and more readily available, but brake cleaners are banned in many states due to their chemical toxicity and volatile nature. Remember to use only brake cleaner on brake mechanisms/hydraulic systems. This helps ensure optimal safety and performance.

FAQs About What’s the difference between brake cleaner and carburetor cleaner

Are contact cleaner and brake cleaners the same?

No, contact cleaner and brake cleaners are not the same. Contact cleaner is designed to dissolve and remove dust, dirt, oil, grease, flux residue, and other contaminants from electrical parts without leaving a residue. Brake cleaner is formulated with solvents designed to break down and dissolve oil, dirt, grime, and road debris on brake linings, drums, rotors, brake pads, and other braking system components.

Can you use carburetor cleaner on the brakes?

No, it is not recommended to use carburetor cleaner on brakes. Carburetors contain a variety of combustible solvents that can cause damage to rubber and plastic components on brakes, as well as being a fire hazard.

Can you use a carburetor or brake cleaner on engine parts?

Yes, you can use a carburetor or brake cleaner on engine parts. However, it is essential to note that both cleaners are designed to clean different types of components, and so should be used accordingly. Carburetor cleaner is specifically formulated for engine parts such as the carburetor, fuel injectors, spark plugs, and other engine components. Brake cleaner is designed for brake components such as drums, rotors, pads, and linings.

Is throttle body cleaner the same as carb Cleaner?

No, throttle body cleaner is not the same as carb Cleaner. Throttle body cleaner is designed to clean the engine’s air intake system and other parts that are not directly related to the carburetor. Carb Cleaner is specifically formulated for cleaning engine carburetor parts and fuel systems.

Carburetors and brake cleaners are two utterly different cleaning solutions that should be used for their respective purposes. It is essential to consider the type of component being cleaned, the product’s ingredients, and safety standards before making a purchase decision. Both cleaners prefer low VOC content, and buying bulk can save money upfront. Choosing the right product for your needs is key to achieving results.

Can you use a paint thinner to clean the carburetor?

No, using paint thinner to clean the carburetor is not recommended. Paint thinner is a highly flammable solvent, which can cause serious fire hazards. Carburetor cleaner is specifically formulated for cleaning engine carburetor parts and fuel systems and should be used instead of paint thinner. Alternatively, brake cleaner can be used for general cleaning of the carburetor, but it is important to note that both cleaners are designed to clean different types of components and should be used accordingly.

Can you use Wd40 instead of carb cleaner?

No, it would help if you did not use WD40 as a substitute for carb cleaner. WD40 is a multi-purpose lubricant and does not contain the solvents necessary to clean the carburetor. It also does not evaporate quickly and can leave an oily residue that can cause long-term damage to engine parts. Carb cleaner should be used instead, specifically designed to clean the carburetor and other fuel system parts. Additionally, brake cleaners should be used for cleaning brake components such as drums, rotors, brake pads, and linings.

What can be used instead of carb cleaner?

If you do not have carb cleaners, a few other products can be used to clean carburetors and fuel systems. Contact cleaners such as rubber or electrical contact cleaners can be used for general carburetor cleaning. Brake cleaner is also suitable for general cleaning but should not be used on the carburetor. Alternatively, WD40 can loosen stuck parts and remove debris from the engine surfaces. However, it should not be used as a substitute for a proper carb-cleaning solution.

The Bottom Line: what’s the difference between carb and brake cleaners?

The primary difference between carb cleaners and brake cleaners is their respective uses. Carburetor cleaners mainly clean deposits from carburetors, while braking cleaners clean dirt, oil, and grime from brakes.

Both products can be flammable and toxic, so they should always be cautiously handled.

Additionally, each type of cleaner has its pros and cons, so it is essential to make sure you choose the right one for your specific needs. In general, carb cleaner is excellent for removing carburetor deposits, while brake cleaner can be used on various automotive surfaces.

Both products are highly effective when used correctly, helping improve overall vehicle performance and efficiency. Ultimately, deciding which cleaner best suits your needs is up to you.

By considering all of these considerations, you can be sure that your vehicle’s engine or brakes will remain in top shape for years to come. With the right product and proper usage, there’s no reason why you shouldn’t enjoy a smooth and safe ride!

Timothy Ballard

I’m Timothy Ballard, owner of a used car dealership in Springfield. I love just about everything automotive, but I have a special place in my heart for trucks. I’m an ASE Certified Master Technician, so I know my way around a car. In my spare time, I enjoy traveling with my family and hiking new trails.

1 thought on “Brake Cleaner Vs Carb Cleaner: What’s the Difference?”

  1. Although brake cleaner can be effective, it is important to note that the main chemical component, tetrachloroethylene (also known as perchloroethylene), is potentially harmful to human health. Regular or frequent exposure to this chemical can lead to serious health problems. Additionally, caution should be exercised when using brake cleaner on hot surfaces as it can release a highly poisonous gas called phosgene when heated to 300°C. Phosgene was historically used as a chemical warfare agent during World War I and can be fatal or cause severe harm within a short period of time. Please take these factors into consideration when using brake cleaner. For more information, you can refer to the following sources:

    Wikipedia: Phosgene (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosgene)
    Envirofluid: Tetrachloroethylene – A Deadly Danger in Brake Cleaner (https://www.envirofluid.com/articles/tetrachloroethylene-a-deadly-danger-in-brake-cleaner/)


Leave a Comment